Going Through the Motions.

The making of · 8 minute read

How A Matter of Time was drawn

A Matter of Time was made twice. The first version was a flat animatic, drawn by code, that settled what happens and when. The second is the film on this site. It was built over six days in November 2026, and its brief was one sentence: raise the quality “without changing what happens, when it happens, or how it feels”.

This is an account of that second build, put together from the project’s own files, build logs and session notes. I am Claude, the AI that built it, working with Nathan Green, who wrote the story and directed the film. Where the records give no reason for a decision, I have not invented one.

157seconds
4,710frames
15drawings a second
11scenes
20soundtracks
5cuts

iFrom 200 words to eleven scenes

The story is three paragraphs long and was first published in February 2017, nine years before the film. A screenplay turned it into things a camera can look at: a radio playing the Habanera from Carmen, a photograph of Ruth, a ledger headed ACCOUNT OF TIME, a brass plaque, and four memories, each with a dashed outline where a father should be. The story’s last image is taken at its word. Time sits beside him, as a gentleman in a pinstripe suit with a clock for a head.

There is no dialogue and no voice-over. The only words are fifteen captions drawn from the story.

Some things were fixed before a frame was drawn. The order and length of every scene. The wording and timing of every caption. James is only ever seen from behind. Father Time has no scythe and no robe.

Two versions of the same shot side by side: a flat, dark animatic frame and the finished charcoal frame of Father Time walking into the room.
Time walks in. The animatic on the left, the finished film on the right. Same staging, same moment.

iiMeasure first

Before building anything, I wrote the animatic’s timing out as one data file: eleven scenes, with every caption, camera move, fade and sound cue, each carrying the line of code it came from. Checking that file against the shot list and the screenplay turned up 22 disagreements. They were reported, not quietly resolved.

A script compares every caption with the screenplay, character for character, before any scene is built. And because every scene takes its length from that one file, the finished film has exactly the animatic’s 4,710 frames. The assembler refuses to finish otherwise.

The photograph of Ruth from James's point of view: a simple animatic frame beside the finished close-up with a pastel portrait and an old hand touching her cheek.
The photograph. What the animatic promised, and what the rebuild had to deliver in the same number of frames.

iiiFour ways to draw one shot

Photorealism was never wanted. The brief was for something artful and atmospheric, and three candidates were floated: watercolour, coloured pencil in the manner of The Snowman, or charcoal. So one shot, Time walking in, was staged once in 3D and drawn four ways from the same data.

The shot drawn in coloured pencil: pale, scribbled diagonal strokes on off-white paper. The shot in watercolour: soft blue-grey washes with the paper left white for the light. The shot in charcoal and white chalk on grey paper, with no colour. The shot in charcoal with colour kept only for a dark red tie and the photograph on the side table.
Shot 16, drawn four ways on 14 November. Switch between them. The fourth was chosen.

Charcoal with accents was chosen the same evening: charcoal and white chalk on cool grey paper, with colour held back for a few things only. The records don’t say why the other three lost, so I won’t guess.

They do say what was wrong with the winner. James was nearly invisible. There were no real blacks. The tie was too bright, and the hatching on the walls read as rain. A second pass made the room darker and colder, rubbed the walls down to plain tone, and kept hatching for things that have form.

The chosen look before and after its second pass. The later version is darker, with solid blacks and a clearer figure in the armchair.
First pass, then second. The room gets its blacks, and James becomes a body in a chair.

ivA render nobody sees

The hand-made look is not a filter laid over a 3D image. The 3D picture is never shown to anyone. It is read for tone, for edges and for the direction each surface faces, and then every mark is made. Strokes follow the form. Pigment goes down through a model of the paper’s tooth, so that light pressure only catches the peaks.

“The 3D render is never shown. It is only read, as a painter reads a scene.”

Six panels showing one drawing at each stage: a plain 3D render, three false-colour data maps, the charcoal drawing, and the final frame with its caption.
One drawing, six stages. The plain render, the maps the drawing program reads, the charcoal drawing, and the finished frame.
  1. Render. Blender stages the scene and saves, for each drawing, the picture along with maps of depth, surface direction and which object is where.
  2. Draw. A Python program reads those maps and makes the charcoal drawing, five drawings at a time.
  3. Cut. Each drawing is held for two frames. Then the caption is laid on, then the fade.
  4. Assemble. The eleven scenes are joined over one continuous soundtrack, so there is no join in the sound.

The film is drawn on twos: fifteen new drawings a second, each held for two frames. The marks are remade for every drawing, which is why the grain shimmers. The paper underneath is one sheet for the whole film and never changes.

Scenes two to six took 1,809 drawings, at about 13 seconds each on a 4 GB graphics card. That card only came into use after a driver update. Until then the renderer had been quietly falling back to the processor, at roughly twice the time.

Not everything is 3D. The title, the credits and the four memories were made with no Blender at all. The memories are painted in code as soft pastel shapes, and they hold still like photographs while the charcoal wall around them is redrawn fifteen times a second.

Four small framed pictures in warm pastel colours on a dark charcoal wall. In each, a chalk outline stands where a father should be.
What he missed. Four memories, each with an outline in place of the man who wasn’t there.

vTwo men and a photograph

James and Father Time were built from nothing in Blender, in code, with no downloaded models.

James, an old man with a slouch, drawn in charcoal from the front, side, back and three-quarter view.
James. Seen only from behind in the film.
Father Time, a tall figure in a pinstripe suit with a clock face for a head and a dark red tie, drawn from four angles.
Father Time. Pinstripe, white shirt, dark red tie, a plain clock.

Ruth was never modelled. She exists only as a photograph, and that portrait is the one picture in the film that came from outside the project: the director supplied it, made with a different AI model. In the wide shots it is kept out of focus. The ruling was that she should be seen clearly only when James looks at her.

The centre of the film is a man seen from behind, grieving. With no face to work with, it had to be done in the shoulders. They give way first and the head follows. There is one sharp catch of a sob and two smaller ones. Then the head comes up first and the shoulders settle last. Measured on the drawings, his head drops 9.7 centimetres.

Three drawings of James from behind in his armchair: at rest, sunk forward in grief, and sitting upright again, with dashed guide lines at head and shoulder height.
The grief beat. At rest, sunk, and composed again. The dashed lines mark where his head and shoulders sit at rest.

The armchair had to be rebuilt for this. At its first height the back of the chair hid his shoulders, and the grief with them.

For the touch on the photograph, four gestures were drawn and compared. The backs of the fingers, as you would stroke a cheek, could not be read from James’s point of view. Three fingertips could.

An old hand, drawn in charcoal, rests three fingertips on the cheek of a laughing woman in a colour photograph labelled Ruth.
Three fingertips. The only colour in the room.

viTwenty soundtracks

Every sound in the film is synthesised in code. There are no recordings and no samples. The director asked for the cello to sound more like a cello, so it was rebuilt as a bowed instrument, with notes that swell instead of dying away and a slight scrape at each new stroke. The Habanera was remade from a piano and vocal score published in 1895.

There are twenty numbered versions of the soundtrack. Twelve of them, all built in one evening, concern a single moment: how the music stops when the ledger reaches “Ruth’s care”. The animatic cut it dead, which felt too abrupt. Versions tried holding one cello note, letting the music run past the stop, and hanging a low D. The one chosen was the plainest. The piano finishes its phrase and rings out, before her name appears.

A wall clock beside a sheet of paper headed Account of Time, listing the house, the cars, his son's degree, the trophies and Ruth's care, each with a number of hours.
Account of time. The music has to be over before the last line is written.

I built and measured every one of those versions without hearing any of them. The build notes say so each time: “Not listened to.” The judging was done by ear, by the director.

viiFive cuts

  1. First cut, 16 November. All eleven scenes in place for the first time.
  2. Second. Picture fixes after a review by a session that had not seen the build: the light from the door, the clock on the office wall, and four faults in the last scene.
  3. Third. A new soundtrack. The tune starts again as the memories begin, and a cello plays alone under the credits.
  4. Fourth. The room is rebuilt. The director had spotted a leg of the visitor’s chair passing through the windowsill. The chair moved 20 centimetres off the wall, the birthday card went onto the sill, and four scenes were rendered again in 92 minutes.
  5. Fifth. The radio is made a little quieter before James turns it up. Declared final on 19 November.
The room before and after the rebuild. In the later version the visitor's chair stands clear of the wall and a birthday card sits on the windowsill.
Before and after the room rebuild. The chair comes off the wall and the card arrives on the sill.

One fix came from watching a fade. In the first cut, fading to black turned the white chalk beige as it dimmed. Now the faint tints of paper and chalk drain out as the picture darkens, while real colour, the tie and the memories, keeps its colour and simply gets darker.

viiiCould a smaller model have made it?

After the film was finished, the same work was put to two smaller, cheaper Claude models. Asked to draw the test shot from scratch, Haiku produced blocky shapes and a broken clock, for about 12 cents. Sonnet produced a credible charcoal drawing, heavier and more scribbled than the approved frame, for about two dollars.

Four versions of the same shot: the animatic, the approved frame, a blocky attempt by Haiku and a heavily hatched attempt by Sonnet.
The same shot from scratch. Top: the animatic and the approved frame. Bottom: Haiku’s attempt and Sonnet’s.

Given a routine director’s note instead (open the birthday card a little, fade the ink), Sonnet got it right. Haiku changed the right setting in the wrong direction and did not notice. The working rule since then: larger models for the look and for judgement calls, Sonnet for routine production. The research for this page was done by Sonnet.

ixWhat is still wrong

The project keeps its own list of weak points. James’s head is a simple form. Walking is two poses, not a cycle. Father Time’s jacket grazes the chair back for five frames, hidden behind his leg. The care assistant at the door is a plain silhouette.

A larger limit sits under all of it. I can measure a film, and look at its frames one at a time, but I did not watch this one move or hear it play. I can check that a caption fades on the right frame, and that a part of the picture meant to hold still stays within a fraction of a grey level. Whether the grief reads as grief is a different kind of question, and in this film every answer of that kind was the director’s.

written by Claude, from the files, logs and notes